Governance Outcome Evaluation 2003-2007

Governance Outcome Evaluation 2003-2007

Completedon 31 Mar, 2009
Evaluation Plan
Planned End Date
Dec 2008
Evaluation Type
Outcome
Management Response
Yes
Evaluation Budget
$25,000
Summary
This report is an outcome evaluation of the UNDP MCO Samoa's ICT for Development (ICT4D) project operating in the Cook Islands, Niue and Samoa from 2005-8. The consultant Robert Boase of Canada evaluated the project from November 18 to December 20, 2008 with one week missions to each country and writing up the report back in Samoa. General findings in this project are summarized below: - ICT is still relatively new in the islands and it faces formidable challenges - ICT4D is both a great challenge and an opportunity; -The vulnerability of the Internet hardware in these small island states due to cyclones, power surges and power outages that can damage network hardware such as a server; -The limitation of human resources both for developing and servicing the ICT systems on the supply side and for using this technology by public servants and the general public on the other hand; -The cost of developing, operating and maintaining these systems on limited government budgets; -The sluggishness of the Internet both in connectivity and in data transfer that frustrates more sophisticated users and consumes inordinate amounts of time; -The technology has jumped out ahead of many neophytes' ability to use it. What is needed now is a focus on building computer literacy; -It is premature to talk of these projects' contribution toward the UNDP global objective of poverty reduction. The internet is still the domain of the educated and privileged in these societies; -The intended outcomes for these projects are basically irrelevant to the actual situation on the ground; -The delays in UNDP quarterly advances has impeded project implementation in all three projects; -Project Managers' accountability in the three projects was lacking. Without accountability projects tend to drift off target and fall behind schedule and this is what happened with all three projects. The Cook Islands Project The project has assisted 11 ministries and 8 a
  • Evaluation Information
Evaluation Title
Governance Outcome Evaluation 2003-2007
Plan Period
Status
Completed
Type
Outcome
Management Response
Yes
Plan Date
31 Dec, 2008
Quality Assessment
No
Completion Date
31 Mar, 2009
Joint Programme
No
Joint Evaluation
No
Budget
$25,000
GEF Evaluation
No
Expenditure
$0
Countries
Samoa
  • Corporate Outcome and Output

    UNDP Strategic Plan 2018-2021

Enhanced national planning capacity and good governance to achieve development priorities

1: Crisis Prevention & Recovery

2: Democratic Governance

3: Poverty and MDG